- Ethereum’s cheaper transactions have reduced ETH burning, raising concerns about its long-term value.
- Vitalik Buterin believes ETH’s future should rely more on its store-of-value appeal.
Ethereum has made transactions cheaper by allowing rollups to process activity off-chain and purchase data space on the main network. While this has improved scalability and reduced costs for users, it has also raised questions about how much value these developments generate for ETH holders.
The concern goes beyond lower transaction fees. Ethereum relies partly on transaction fee burning to reduce its circulating supply, but cheaper transactions mean fewer ETH may be destroyed unless network activity increases enough to offset the decline. This creates a challenge for investors trying to understand how network growth translates into demand for ETH.
The debate has also gained attention following comments from Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin on November 8. He argued that ETH’s long-term value should depend more on its qualities as a store of value than on the amount of transaction fees the network burns.
How Ethereum’s Cheaper Transactions Affect ETH Burning
Ethereum uses a fee mechanism that divides transaction payments into two main components: the base fee and the priority fee.
The base fee is burned, permanently removing ETH from circulation. The priority fee goes to the validator responsible for including the transaction in a block. This means that not every ETH paid in transaction fees reduces the token’s supply.
For example, a standard transaction using 21,000 gas with a base fee of 10 gwei and a priority fee of 2 gwei costs 0.000252 ETH. Of this amount, 0.00021 ETH is burned, while the remaining 0.000042 ETH goes to the validator.
However, when the base fee falls, the amount of ETH burned also declines if gas usage remains unchanged. This creates a direct connection between transaction costs and Ethereum’s supply dynamics.
The effect becomes clearer when ETH’s dollar price is considered separately. If the token trades at $2,000, the example transaction costs approximately $0.50. If ETH’s price doubles, the same transaction costs approximately $1.01 in dollar terms, even though the amount of ETH burned remains unchanged.
Therefore, higher dollar-denominated fee revenue does not necessarily mean that Ethereum is burning more ETH. Investors need to distinguish between the token’s market price and the actual amount destroyed through transaction fees.
Rollups Have Reduced Costs, but Ethereum Earns Less Per Transaction
Ethereum’s scaling strategy relies heavily on rollups, which process transactions outside the main network before posting the necessary data back to Ethereum.
This approach allows multiple transactions to share the cost of using Ethereum’s infrastructure. Instead of every user paying separately for mainnet execution, rollup operators combine activity into batches and pay Ethereum for the data needed to support their operations.
The introduction of blob transactions through EIP-4844 created a separate fee market for this data. As a result, demand for blob space does not necessarily produce the same fee movements as demand for ordinary execution gas.
For Ethereum users, this arrangement has made transactions more affordable. However, lower costs also mean that Ethereum may collect less in fees for each transaction processed through a rollup.
Consider a hypothetical rollup operator that pays 1 ETH to post a batch containing 100,000 transactions. Its average posting cost is 0.00001 ETH per transaction. If the same payment covers 200,000 transactions, the average cost falls to 0.000005 ETH.
Although twice as many transactions are processed, Ethereum still receives just 1 ETH in this example.
This explains why rising transaction counts do not automatically translate into higher Ethereum revenue. Investors must also consider how much rollup operators actually pay to use the network.
Ethereum Needs More Activity to Offset Lower Fees
Lower transaction costs can attract more users and applications, but increased activity must be substantial enough to compensate for the reduction in fees.
A simple example illustrates the challenge. If one million transactions each use 21,000 gas at a base fee of 10 gwei, Ethereum burns 210 ETH.
If the base fee falls to 1 gwei while gas usage remains unchanged, the same number of transactions generates just 21 ETH in burns. Ethereum would need ten million otherwise identical transactions to reach the previous 210 ETH burn.
This does not mean cheaper transactions are necessarily bad for Ethereum. Lower fees can encourage adoption, improve the user experience and make applications more competitive.
However, transaction growth alone is not enough to establish that ETH benefits financially from increased network activity. The amount users pay and the resulting ETH burn remain important.
The distinction also matters when measuring Ethereum’s supply. Investors need to compare total issuance with total ETH burned over the same period.
For example, if Ethereum issues 80,000 ETH in a month and burns 50,000 ETH, its net supply increases by 30,000 ETH. If burning rises to 90,000 ETH while issuance remains unchanged, supply contracts by 10,000 ETH.
This makes net supply a more useful measure than transaction counts when assessing whether Ethereum is experiencing inflation or deflation.
EIP-7918 Could Change Ethereum’s Blob Fee Economics
Ethereum is also working on changes to improve how its data fee market operates.
One important development is EIP-7918, which introduces a reserve-price mechanism connecting blob fees to execution costs. The proposal addresses situations where blob fees become so low that they no longer adequately reflect the other costs associated with posting data.
Its parameters include 8,192 execution-gas units and 131,072 blob-gas units per blob, creating a one-sixteenth reference relationship between the two markets.
The mechanism is designed to prevent blob fees from falling too far below the cost of execution resources under the specified conditions.
EIP-7918 is included in Ethereum’s Fusaka upgrade specifications. However, the reserve-price mechanism should not be confused with a guaranteed increase in transaction fees or ETH burning.
Actual fees will still depend on network demand, available capacity and the amount of data rollups need to post.
This distinction is important because improvements to Ethereum’s capacity do not automatically translate into higher revenue for ETH holders.
Staking Offers ETH Holders Another Way to Earn Returns
Transaction fee burning is not the only factor influencing the economics of holding ETH. Staking also provides a way for investors to earn additional tokens by participating in Ethereum’s proof-of-stake system.
However, staking rewards and ETH burning serve different purposes. Staking rewards compensate validators for securing the network, while burning permanently removes tokens from circulation.
Ethereum’s issuance depends partly on how much ETH is staked. As a result, the amount validators receive can change depending on network participation.
Sygnum highlighted this distinction in its November 12 announcement of a new ETH fund targeting annual net returns of 8% to 10% in ETH. This compares with the bank’s quoted conventional staking return range of approximately 2% to 3%.
The fund combines staking with options premiums, arbitrage and derivatives funding strategies to generate additional income. Its objective is to increase the amount of ETH investors hold rather than provide a guaranteed return in dollars.
For example, an investor holding 100 ETH could increase that balance to 109 ETH after earning a hypothetical 9% return. However, if ETH’s dollar price falls from $2,000 to $1,600 during the same period, the investment’s value declines from $200,000 to $174,400.
This highlights an important risk for investors. Earning more ETH does not necessarily mean making a profit in dollar terms.
The fund also carries risks involving counterparties, staking, liquidity, smart contracts and trading strategies. Its targeted return should therefore not be treated as a guaranteed yield or as income distributed directly by Ethereum’s protocol.
Vitalik Buterin Wants ETH’s Value to Depend on More Than Transaction Fees
The debate over Ethereum’s fee economics has also brought attention to Vitalik Buterin’s comments on November 8.
Buterin argued that ETH’s long-term value should rely more on its qualities as a store of value, supported by decentralization, censorship resistance, privacy and security.
He did not suggest removing Ethereum’s fee-burning mechanism. Instead, he questioned whether maximizing transaction fees should become the network’s main objective.
This argument challenges the idea that Ethereum must generate increasingly large transaction fees to justify ETH’s value. If the network becomes more efficient and cheaper to use, lower fees could be a sign of progress rather than a failure. However, that progress does not automatically translate into stronger demand for ETH.
Buterin also questioned whether fee-based valuation models can provide a reliable picture of ETH’s long-term worth. He used a hypothetical $1 billion in annual ETH burning and a 4% discount rate to illustrate a $25 billion valuation. However, that calculation assumes the annual burn continues indefinitely, which becomes difficult to justify if network activity and transaction fees fluctuate.
His position is that Ethereum’s long-term value should also come from people wanting to hold ETH, rather than relying primarily on the amount destroyed through transaction fees.
This creates two different ways to assess the asset. The fee-based argument focuses on demand for Ethereum’s settlement and data services, while the store-of-value argument looks at whether investors want to hold ETH as collateral, reserves or a long-term asset.
Both forms of demand matter, but they are not interchangeable. More transactions can increase network usage without creating an equivalent increase in demand to hold ETH.
What Ethereum’s Cheaper Transactions Mean for ETH Investors
Ethereum’s cheaper transactions represent an important improvement for users and applications, but they also expose a challenge in the network’s economic model. Lower fees reduce the amount of ETH burned per transaction, while increased activity must grow enough to compensate for that decline.
For investors, the bigger question is whether Ethereum can turn its growing ecosystem into sustained demand for ETH. Transaction fees and supply changes remain important, but staking, collateral use and long-term holding demand also influence the asset’s economics.
The key distinction is that a more successful Ethereum network does not automatically guarantee a higher ETH price. Its long-term value will depend on whether increased adoption creates enough demand to support the token, even as the cost of using the network continues to fall.
ALSO READ: XRP Price Risks Drop to $0.50 if the Critical $1 Support Level Breaks
DISCLAIMER:
This article reflects the author’s views and is provided for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, the publisher does not guarantee that all information is complete or current. Readers should verify important information and consult appropriate sources before making decisions based on this content.
